Parenting Time vs. Decision Making Authority: Critical Decisions in Colorado Custody Cases

May 12, 2025 | Child Custody

Understanding the crucial difference between parenting time vs. decision making authority is essential for any parent navigating the Colorado custody system. At Perkins Law, we’ve guided hundreds of Colorado Springs families through this complex legal landscape, fighting to protect their relationships with their children while securing their parental rights.

When courts determine custody arrangements—now legally referred to as “parental responsibilities” in Colorado—they evaluate parenting time vs. decision making authority separately. This often leads to arrangements where one parent may have significant time with their children but limited authority to make important decisions about their lives.

This distinction can profoundly impact your relationship with your children for years to come. It affects everything from your day-to-day interactions to your influence over their education, healthcare, and religious upbringing.

You deserve an advocate who understands both the technical legal requirements and the deeply emotional nature of these proceedings—someone who will stand firmly by your side throughout this challenging process.

The Colorado Framework: Parenting Time vs. Decision Making Authority

The Colorado legal system approaches custody through a framework that carefully separates parenting time vs. decision making authority, treating them as distinct components of parental responsibilities. When you enter the family court system in Colorado Springs, judges are required by law to determine these elements independently of each other.

Parenting time (previously called physical custody) refers to the schedule determining when your child will be in your care. This includes the actual hours and days you spend with them, including overnights, holidays, school breaks, and special occasions.

Decision-making authority (formerly called legal custody) involves your right to participate in significant decisions affecting your child’s life. This includes educational choices, medical treatments, religious upbringing, and extracurricular activities.

The court can allocate these responsibilities in various combinations. You might have equal parenting time but unequal decision making authority or limited time but equal input into major decisions.

At Perkins Law, we’ve represented countless Colorado Springs parents in these proceedings. We develop strategic parenting plans that protect both meaningful time with children and appropriate authority in critical decisions.

parenting time vs. decision making in colorado springs

Parenting Time: Beyond Just Visitation

When Colorado courts determine parenting time vs. decision making authority, they’re addressing far more than just when you’ll “visit” with your child. They’re establishing the foundation of your ongoing parent-child relationship.

Have you considered how the specific schedule ordered by the court will affect not just weekends and holidays but also your ability to participate in everyday moments? Parenting time encompasses everything from morning routines and bedtime rituals to homework help, doctor’s appointments, and school events.

Colorado law presumes that children benefit from having substantial time with both parents. However, this doesn’t automatically translate to a 50/50 schedule.

The court considers numerous factors when establishing parenting time. These include your child’s age and developmental needs, your historical role in their care, your work schedule, the distance between parents’ homes, and your ability to place your child’s needs above conflict.

At Perkins Law, we understand that maximizing meaningful parenting time requires both compelling legal advocacy and practical solutions. You need an arrangement that allows you to maintain deep connections with your children, not just see them occasionally.

You Might Like: Navigating the Holidays With Shared Parenting Time

Decision-Making Authority: Your Voice in Critical Choices

While parenting time affects your day-to-day relationship with your child, decision-making authority determines your role in shaping their future. Have you thought about who will decide which school your child attends, what medical treatments they receive, or how they’re raised spiritually if you and your co-parent disagree?

Decision-making authority in Colorado can be allocated jointly (requiring parents to consult and agree), primarily to one parent (giving them the final say after consultation), or divided by domain (where one parent might make educational decisions while the other handles medical matters).

The court’s determination of parenting time vs. decision making authority hinges on factors including your historical involvement in these decisions and your demonstrated capacity to communicate effectively with the other parent. They also consider your willingness to support your child’s relationship with the other parent, as well as any history of domestic violence or inability to cooperate.

Colorado judges are increasingly reluctant to award joint decision-making when there’s evidence of significant conflict. They believe that forcing hostile parents to collaborate often leads to harmful impasses.

At Perkins Law, we build strategic cases that highlight your history of sound judgment, reasonable cooperation, and child-centered decision-making.

parenting time vs. decision making in colorado springs

When Parenting Time and Decision-Making Conflict

One of the most challenging aspects of Colorado’s parental responsibility framework is navigating situations where there’s a significant mismatch between parenting time vs. decision making authority allocations. These hybrid arrangements can create substantial practical complications.

Have you considered how you’ll handle having your children in your care regularly while having limited input into important decisions affecting them? Or conversely, having decision-making authority but limited time to implement and monitor those decisions?

These scenarios often lead to ongoing conflict, with children caught in the middle as parents struggle to navigate disconnected responsibilities. The challenges are particularly acute around daily decisions that blur the line between parenting time choices and major life decisions.

At Perkins Law, we advocate for coherent parenting plans that align decision-making authority with the practical realities of parenting time when possible. When different allocations are necessary, we establish clear protocols for communication and implementation.

Related: Tips for Choosing a Child Support Attorney in Colorado Springs

The “Best Interest” Standard in Colorado Courts

Colorado courts determine parenting time vs. decision making authority based on the “best interest of the child” standard. Many parents are surprised to learn how this standard is actually applied in practice.

Have you wondered exactly what factors judges consider when deciding what arrangement would best serve your child’s well-being? While Colorado law provides general guidelines, the interpretation varies significantly among judges, particularly in El Paso County.

The court considers factors including the wishes of the parents and the child (if sufficiently mature), the child’s relationships with family members, and the child’s adjustment to home, school, and community. They also evaluate the mental and physical health of all parties and each parent’s ability to support the child’s continued relationship with the other parent.

Critically, Colorado law specifically prohibits courts from considering gender when allocating parental responsibilities. There is no legal presumption favoring mothers over fathers.

At Perkins Law, we’ve appeared before every family court judge in Colorado Springs. This gives us insight into how each typically applies these standards and what evidence proves most compelling in their courtroom.

Modification of Parenting Time vs. Decision Making Authority

After initial parental responsibility orders are established, Colorado law sets different standards for modifying parenting time vs. decision making authority. This reflects the court’s view of their relative impact on children’s stability.

For parenting time modifications, Colorado employs a tiered approach. Minor adjustments require showing that the modification is in the child’s best interest. Substantial changes require that the requesting parent demonstrates that the current arrangement endangers the child’s physical health or emotional development.

For decision-making modifications, the court generally requires evidence of new circumstances that make the existing allocation no longer in the child’s best interest. An even higher standard applies if one parent seeks to move from joint to sole decision-making authority.

The court is particularly resistant to modifications sought primarily due to parental conflict rather than genuine changes affecting the child’s well-being.

At Perkins Law, we help clients both defend against unwarranted modification attempts and pursue necessary changes when circumstances genuinely warrant adjustment.

Special Considerations: High-Conflict Cases

When determining parenting time vs. decision making authority in high-conflict cases, Colorado Springs family court judges apply specialized approaches. These are designed to minimize children’s exposure to ongoing parental discord.

Have you worried about how persistent conflict with your co-parent might affect the court’s custody decisions? High levels of parental conflict significantly influence judicial decision-making, often leading to more structured arrangements with limited direct interaction between parents.

In these situations, judges frequently order detailed parenting time schedules with minimal transition contact and specific communication protocols. In the most severe cases, the court may require supervised exchanges or professional parent coordinators.

Regarding decision-making authority, courts are increasingly reluctant to order joint decision-making in high-conflict cases. Instead, they may allocate primary decision-making to one parent or divide authority by domain to reduce the need for cooperation.

At Perkins Law, our attorneys specialize in high-conflict child custody cases. We develop strategic approaches that protect your parental role while acknowledging relationship dynamics that may concern the court.

parenting time vs. decision making in colorado springs

Practical Implementation: Making Your Parenting Plan Work

Beyond the legal distinctions between parenting time vs. decision making authority, the practical implementation of these arrangements determines whether they truly serve your child’s best interests. Even the most carefully crafted court orders can fail without practical mechanisms for implementation.

Effective parenting plans include detailed processes for information sharing and specific communication methods for decision-making discussions. They establish clear procedures for handling emergency decisions and explicit processes for resolving disagreements before returning to court.

They address practical questions like how a parent with decision-making authority but limited parenting time will gather sufficient information about the child’s needs. They also establish boundaries between major decisions requiring consultation and day-to-day choices made during each parent’s time.

At Perkins Law, we craft comprehensive parenting plans that move beyond legal frameworks to address these practical realities. We draw on our experience with what works in real Colorado families.

Technology and Co-Parenting: Modern Solutions

In contemporary custody arrangements, technology offers powerful tools for addressing challenges in implementing parenting time vs. decision making authority allocations. Have you explored how specialized co-parenting technology might help you navigate these responsibilities more effectively?

Modern co-parenting apps provide secure messaging platforms that document all communications and shared calendars to prevent scheduling conflicts. They offer information repositories for school and medical records and structured formats for decision-making discussions.

For families where direct communication exacerbates conflict, these platforms create sufficient distance to maintain necessary parental coordination without triggering harmful interactions.

Colorado courts increasingly recognize the value of these tools, sometimes ordering their use in high-conflict cases or when parents struggle with consistent information sharing.

At Perkins Law, we help clients select and implement technological solutions tailored to their specific co-parenting challenges.

Taking Action: Securing Your Parental Rights Today

The allocation of parenting time vs. decision making authority will shape your relationship with your children for years to come. This makes strategic legal representation essential for protecting these fundamental parental rights.

Are you ready to take concrete steps toward securing the parenting arrangement your children deserve? The decisions made during custody proceedings often have far-reaching consequences that extend well beyond childhood.

Delays in seeking qualified legal guidance can result in temporary arrangements becoming permanent, positions hardening, and critical evidence being lost. The Colorado family court system presents complex procedural requirements and timelines that must be navigated precisely.

At Perkins Law, we believe that every parent deserves a powerful advocate who understands both the legal intricacies of parental responsibility allocation and the emotional significance of maintaining meaningful parent-child relationships.

Don’t face this challenging process alone. Schedule your free, confidential consultation with our child custody lawyers today. Together, we’ll develop a customized strategy to protect your relationship with your children and secure your voice in their future.

Get Started NOW!

Click to request a consultation or give us a call and speak with a local divorce lawyer in Colorado Springs now.